Wes Baker

Review: Spire

November 13th, 2018

Cover of Spire

To date, I’ve played in exactly one Powered by the Apocalypse RPG and only one session: The Sprawl. I thoroughly enjoyed myself with that, but I preface this review with that so you understand that I haven’t played this game and I haven’t seen many other PbtA games.

Spire is a game about being oppressed, downtrodden, and treated as less than human. It’s about rising up from those oppressors—the Aelfir—and figuring out a way to fight back. It’s about being a revolutionary, a firebrand, a subtle manipulator, and about sacrifices. Do you level a city block of innocents to really stick it to the Aelfir?

You are a drow elf in your native city, but it has been conquered by the high elves, the Aelfir. You are a member of the Ministry, a group of like-minded, but independent, members in different cells. Your job is to do what you can to overthrow the Aelfir.

The Mechanics

Spire is definitely related to Powered by the Apocalypse games. However, instead of the typical roll 2D6 where 6- is a miss, 7-9 is a weak hit, and 10+ is a strong hit, you’ll be rolling a pool of D10s. The number you roll depends on your skills, the domain (your knowledge and expertise of location within the spire), and mastery of a skill. So at most, you’ll be rolling 4D10. In addition, a situation could be difficult, in that case you may be rolling with 1-2 fewer dice (if you lose more dice than you have you still roll at least one die, your success is a notch or two lower depending on the number of dice you couldn’t lose).

The results are similar to PbtA games, but a D10 offers more granularity:

  • 1: Critical failure (double stress)
  • 2-5: Failure (stress)
  • 6-7: Success at a cost (stress)
  • 8-9: Success
  • 10: Critical success (inflict stress per 10 you roll)

Stress is Spire’s way of indicating that hit points aren’t the only way to take damage. You have five resistances: Blood, Mind, Silver (money), Shadow, and Reputation. When you take stress, you take either a fixed amount (e.g. 1, 3) or a dice roll (e.g. D3, D4, D6, D8) to a given resistance track minus filling your character’s resistance slots first. When you take that stress the GM will roll a D10 and if it’s lower than your current stress total (ignoring your resistance slots), you’ll take fallout. So if you took 7 Blood damage and had 2 Blood resistance slots, you’d check off your Blood resistance slots and have a total of 5 stress.

Fallouts are a way of taking “damage” in the game, though the damage might be to your Reputation or your Shadow instead of just your health. Fallout ranges from minor to severe. When you take a fallout, you’ll lower your overall fallout by an amount and then deal with the fallout. Some examples:

  • Minor: Compromised [Shadow]: A friendly NPC asks you to justify your strange behavior.
  • Moderate: Broken Arm [Blood]: Your arm breaks under the strain, and splintered bone juts up through your skin. You can’t use the arm until it heals (which will take a month or so, or require powerful healing magic).
  • Severe: Renegade [Mind]: Your mind shattered by the stress of your actions, you turn against the Ministry and all it stands for (the precise reasons why are up to you and the GM). This is not immediate; the fallout represents the first crack in the dam of your mind. Over the next few sessions, play out your descent. Should you survive, you join a rival faction, or become one unto yourself, set against the cell.

Beyond that, there are some mechanics for Bonds between different player characters, there’s a list of suggested equipment and tags for newly made equipment, rules for combat, and rules for advancement. I particularly like the advancement rules: you ask yourselves if you’ve made a small, moderate, or large change inSpire. Then you get an advance matching that.


Firebrand character from Spire

Like most PbtA games, each character will pick a playbook. However, there aren’t the typical stats in most PbtA games, instead you have skills, domains, and resistances (and resistance slots). Skills and domains are binary: you either have them or you don’t. Resistance slots are numerical and function as “armor” to a given resistance.

There are 10 playbooks players can pick from:

  • Azurite: A merchant with connections everywhere
  • Bound: A vigilante with gods in their equipment
  • Carrion-Priest: A priest of a heretical sect who has a holy hyena
  • Firebrand: A revolutionary, a rabble-rouser, you bring the people
  • Idol: An artist and revolutionary, you create things that sway people
  • Knight: A likely-corrupt, sword-carrying gangster
  • Lajhan: A priest of the Aelfir deity, a healer
  • Masked: A master of subterfuge and going unnoticed
  • Midwife: A keeper of the drow race, blessed with an arachnid bloodline
  • Vermissian Sage: A historian of the Vermissian, a non-euclidian transport network

Every playbook feels unique and decidedly non-traditional. If you’re bored of your typical fantasy RPG, these will feel different.

Districts and Factions

Map of Spire

The meat of Spire is its ~90 pages of district and faction information. I remember reading somewhere that the designers wanted to create a Powered by the Apocalypse game that had an established setting and between the playbooks and these pages, they pretty much nailed it. Sure, you could move these things to a different game, but they’re so consistent here that it’d be strange to.

I think my favorite district is Perch. I love the flavor that it’s this collection of buildings “strapped, nailed, or bolted to the outer wall of Spire”. Between that mental image and the Bound that patrol the district, it hit the right notes for me. For factions, The Sect of Our Crimson Vigil brings in the right amount of righteous indignation for me and I’d love roleplaying as a member.

Running the Game and Appendixes

The Running the Game section is filled with largely useful, but well-trodden, suggestions. I appreciated that they included the Lines (don’t cross this line) and Veils (we can talk about it, but don’t detail it) that they use for their games as it helps better understand it’s purpose as a safety rule.

The one part that caught my eye was the section on brutal violence:

Combat is not glorious, even if it’s undeniably effective, and that person you killed has a name and loved ones waiting at home and was probably just doing their job. Let players engage in violence, and then pull no punches as to the descriptions. Make them regret their decisions. Make their opponents pathetic and scared and shuddering and humanised in their final moments. (And if you can, give every single person a name, and maybe have their friends shout it out when they die.)

I think there’s a time and place for “I kill the goblin and loot it’s body” and I enjoy that kind of play, but I also think there’s a time and place for the kind of roleplaying where your players keenly feel the deaths of NPCs.

The Appendixes are the last up and there’s some useful stuff in there: new gods, a glossary, a table of goats, arcologies (though why are you leaving Spire?), and suggested media (an Appendix N if you will). However, I love random tables and find them the most useful and there are two appendixes of random tables: Random Items and Events, and Antagonists. With these two, you can answer questions about why things are they way they are, create a unique situation in your Spire, and setup a campaign with some small-time and big-time antagonists.

Final Thoughts

I haven’t played Spire yet, but I want to. This is a unique setting and an interesting take on a fantasy world. You could easily treat this as a sourcebook and use different systems or you could try out their take on Powered by the Apocalypse and be just as satisfied.

For me, I’ll probably put this on my list of games-to-play-online as I’m trying to run a regular RPG group online with some of my friends where we can try out different systems and games.

For you, if you’re into Powered by the Apocalypse games—in particular Blades in the Dark—then I think you’d enjoy this one and should play it close to rules-as-written. If Powered by the Apocalypse isn’t your jam, then I think you owe it to yourself to pick this one up as a PDF and use the districts and factions along with the random charts in the appendixes and use it in your system of choice. (I could also see resigning the playbooks as OSR classes, though you’d need to figure out a way to bring over the resistances.)